How to add speeds; Galileo and Einstein won’t agree.

How to calculate the speed of anything, when their speed becomes closer to the speed-of-light

This article was originally a comment in the linked article;  Why Nothing Moves Faster Than Light.

— In order to correct the comment I have made earlier  ” unless something is completely mass-less in its rest-frame ” I also add the following. This is a fact which I have realized lately — or rather trapped myself to commit an inconsistent remark, by following the same comment in making other remarks elsewhere.

But it’s better late than never to realize; when something is mass-less, it will never have a rest-frame, because by Einstein’s transformation rules, known as Theory of Relativity, to be consistent, a mass-less particle will always move at the speed of light c, no matter which frame we are looking at it from. This then leads to the velocity addition formula of Einstein.

Now we will discuss in a slightly more detail the two kind of velocity addition formula, one prior to Einstein and one that came from Einstein’s work.

Prior to Einstein

According to Newton and Galileo ( Galileo Project ), known by a name Galilean Relativity, the following follows; if C moves at speed v_{CB} wrt B, B moves at speed v_{BA} wrt A then C must move at speed v_{CA} wrt A, given by v_{CA} = v_{CB} + v_{BA}. The speeds get added up, the reason why the formula is known as velocity addition formula in the realm of Newtonian or Galilean mechanics.

Portrait of Galileo Photo Credit; galileo dot rice dot edu

Portrait of Galileo Photo Credit; galileo dot rice dot edu 

Galileo Galilei with his famous quote. Photo Credit: er dot uqam dot ca

Galileo Galilei with his famous quote. Photo Credit: er dot uqam dot ca

Newton. Photo Credit; Beforeitnews dot com

Newton. Photo Credit; Beforeitnews dot com

Newton Photo Credit; topinfopost dot com

Newton Photo Credit; topinfopost dot com

Let’s take this simple example, to illustrate the above; A bullet moves at speed 200 km/hr in a train and the train moves at 250 km/hr wrt Jason, who is standing still, on ground, all in the same global direction. Lets denote ground to be A, train to be B and bullet to be C.

So Jason will see that the bullet will move at speed 200 + 250 = 450 \frac{km}{hr} Thus Galilean Relativity: v_{CA} = v_{CB} + v_{BA}.

Note i.  B as an index vanishes, if we keep the indices in proper sequence. CA = CB + BA.

Note ii. This relation is most generally valid as a vector equation as well. There are 3 vectors here in the given equation, for the respective speeds.

Photo Credit; convdocs.org Frames can be attached to cars, for reference of motion and speeds of the car becomes that of the frame of reference.

Frames can be attached to cars, for reference of motion and speeds of the car becomes that of the frame of reference. Photo Credit; convdocs dot org 

The above is another example of how speeds get added in Galilean way, here resulting speed seen by the ground observer is 8 + 15 = 23 \frac{m}{s}.

Post Einstein’s work of relativity

But Einstein modified this, to make the rule consistent, with how it will work out for light or any relay of information at that speed. To make light always move at speed c = 2.99 \times 10^8 \frac{m}{s} the simple addition becomes warped.

Albert Einstein: the inventor of theory of relativity among other important knowledge in physics.

Albert Einstein: the inventor of theory of relativity among other important knowledge in physics.

It’s still known as addition of velocities or addition of speed and given by v_{CA} = \frac{v_{CB}+v_{BA}}{1+v_{CB}v_{BA}} where we have to use speeds in the unit of speed of light being 1, ie, speeds as fractions of the value of c and we will get the results in terms of speed of light being 1 as well.

We then simply multiply c = 2.99 \times 10 ^8 \frac{m}{s} to that fraction, to get the exact speed, in terms of \frac{m}{s} ( or subsequently \frac{km}{hr} ) etc. Not only we have to multiply this value of c to any result we obtain from this formula, we also have to divide this value before carrying out any calculation, in order to use the formula, given in this form.

Light, an electromagnetic wave phenomena propagates at the speed of 3,00,000 kms/s. Photo Credit; abduzeedo.com

Light, an electromagnetic wave phenomena propagates at the speed of 3,00,000 kms/s. Photo Credit; abduzeedo.com

— Literature will make it slightly more complicated, and less attractive, for modern physicists, to get consistent results in \frac{m}{s} ( \frac{km}{hr} ).

So  Einstein’s Relativity:  v_{CA} = \frac{v_{CB}+v_{BA}}{1+v_{CB}v_{BA}} . When this factor 1+v_{CB}v_{BA}  is divided, its no more a simple addition, but a warped addition and it is known as Einstein Velocity Addition Formula.

This article has a good deal of similitude of content with the linked:Why Nothing Moves Faster Than Light— so they can be read together.



Categories: basic physics, classical mechanics, Physics, Relativity, relativity theory, Teaching, Vectors

Tags: , , , , ,

3 replies

Trackbacks

  1. Whats Pseudo Force? — Is Gravity amenable to Quantization? « Invariance Publishing House !
  2. The energy loss of OPERA neutrino, aberration, rest the anomaly – "Invariance" from M Dash Foundation
  3. Introduction to special theory of relativity. – "Invariance" from M Dash Foundation

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s